Onge's Review

Three years after the release of Total Pop! - The First 40 Hits (Erasure's most comprehensive collection of the band's singles to date) another Erasure compilation, entitled Essential, was released in March 2012. Part of the EMI Gold range which also saw compilations by Yazoo, UB40, Human League, Kim Wilde, Blondie and Roxy Music amongst others released under the same moniker, Erasure's Essential CD is home to 16 tracks from the band's back catalogue spanning 1985 to 2003. Undoubtedly the 16 songs chosen are a curious bunch with many big songs such as A Little Respect, Stop!, Chains Of Love, Blue Savannah, Love To Hate You and Take A Chance On Me all noticeable by their absences. Arguably the only bona fide hit singles present are Sometimes, Victim Of Love, Chorus and Always - somewhat meagre pickings considering Erasure's sizeable collection of top 5 UK singles. Instead Essential is home to some of the band's lesser-known singles such as You Surround Me, Am I Right?, It Doesn't Have To Be, Star and I Love Saturday.

Despite the various misgivings, there are still a lot of great tracks to be found on Essential and whilst it's clearly not aimed at hardcore fans, there is still a lot to recommend about this release, especially the budget price.

There is no doubting these are still terrific songs, but if you buy an artist's "essential" compilation it's not unreasonable to expect more in the way of well-known hits singles. And if you're particularly pedantic the fact the tracklisting isn't in chronological order might be slightly irritating. What is more perplexing is that four tracks (that's a quarter of the album) come from Erasure's much-maligned cover versions album from 2003, Other People's Songs. Of these only Make Me Smile (Come Up & See Me) was released as single, meaning the top 10 single from this album, Solsbury Hill, is other noticeable absentee. Presumably the three other songs chosen are selected because the average person is familiar with the originals, but frankly there is no way on Earth that the horrible, substandard b-side quality cover of Video Killed The Radio Star could ever be considered "essential" (for me, it's one of the worst ever Erasure recordings).


Unquestionably the title to this compilation is dubious at best, with the tracklisting rarely showcasing the hit singles that have defined Erasure's career. What would have been welcome is if EMI had the courage to add a few top album tracks in instead of a collection of cover versions - the likes of Hideaway, Waiting For The Day, Take Me Back and Save Me Darling deserve to be enjoyed by a wider audience and would surely still delight casual fans. Likewise, most of Erasure's post-1994 singles are overlooked once again which feels like a missed opportunity to promote some great but under-heard songs from this era. Still, despite the various misgivings, there are still a lot of great tracks to be found on Essential and whilst it's clearly not aimed at hardcore fans, there is still a lot to recommend about this release, especially the budget price. By not mimicking other best of compilations, it can still act as a decent companion to the likes of Pop! or Hits!. But if you're on the hunt for your first Erasure compilation album, I'd urge you to check out Total Pop! The First 40 Hits instead - it is better in every single way, and is substantially more essential.

Fan Reviews

Below are some fan reviews written by visitors to this very site. Once you've read these, please feel free to use the form at the end of the page to write your own review.

  1. I have ABSOLUTELY no idea why this compilation was ever released.

    2 out of 10
    Reviewed by Lucie Czech republic
    24 March 2012 7:25 pm (GMT)
  2. eclectic mix of erasure hits and less known album tracks. good value for the price. not a patch on total pop or pop but a reasonably good mix of tracks. though hardly essential

    7 out of 10
    Reviewed by Paraic
    25 April 2012 10:02 pm (GMT)
  3. Great tunes and some really nice pieces from the past.

    9 out of 10
    Reviewed by Ahti-Kullervo Jõgi
    27 June 2012 4:38 pm (GMT)
  4. This is a weird compilation in a bad moment.
    The problem is that they didn’t need a new compilation after havig released Total Pop! The First 40 Hits.
    Perhaps EMI wanted to catch buyers with some uncomprehensible tracks from the album Other People’s Songs such as When Will I See You Again, Video Killed the Radio Star and Everybody’s Got to Learn Sometime, all songs which don’t show the real “Essence” of Erasure .
    If the idea was to include non single songs, it would have been better to choose those which were played on the radio and clubs like Knocking on Your Door or Hideaway.
    The rest of the album is full of hits and brilliant songs (The songs that you metioned as lesser-known singles such as You Surround Me, Am I Right?, It Doesn’t Have To Be, Star and I Love Saturday were all of them UK Top 20 -Star reached the 11 place-).
    It’s a pity


    4 out of 10
    Reviewed by Hernán
    26 July 2012 7:23 pm (GMT)
  5. Bizzare compilation as only a few of the tracks on here could be considered as part of the group’s best of canon, or indeed essential.
    If you were to introduce a new listener to the band you would never start here, but rather would point them in the direction of POP or Total POP or at least Hits! The low price of this budget compilation reflections some of the lesser content within.

    5 out of 10
    Reviewed by Pmr31
    2 July 2013 3:49 pm (GMT)
  6. Low budget and ill-conceived compilation.

    If you really want to discover ERASURE – or to make people discover the band -, please buy the much more appropriate compilation “Total Pop! The First 40 Hits” (2009) instead of this poor one !

    3 out of 10
    Reviewed by Erwann Le GARREC, France
    20 March 2016 10:54 pm (GMT)

Review this album

Use the form below to write your own review of this album. Your review can be a few sentences long or several paragraphs - the length is entirely up to you.